Will AI Replace Legal Review? U.S. Lawyers Weigh Automation Risks

Artificial intelligence has entered nearly every corner of U.S. law practice—from discovery to drafting. Nowhere is the change more visible than in document review, once the most time-consuming task for attorneys and paralegals.

Unlock Legal Insights Instantly!

The question many are asking: Can AI really replace human legal review?

The short answer: no. But the longer story shows how AI is reshaping roles, changing workflows, and forcing firms to confront both opportunity and risk.

The Rapid Rise of AI in Review

Big Law firms are already adopting automation in legal review. Reports show that leading firms like Sidley Austin and DLA Piper are piloting AI assistants for discovery, contracts, and compliance tasks. Partners highlight faster turnaround times and reduced costs, but they also admit oversight is non-negotiable.

Studies back this up: AI can reduce review hours by as much as 50%, freeing up attorneys for higher-value strategy and client work. Yet even the most advanced tools still hallucinate or overgeneralize, which makes unsupervised use dangerous.

Why Efficiency Isn’t the Whole Story

Gains

• Research shows AI-driven review can save the average U.S. attorney up to 100 hours per year.
• Spellbook and other platforms claim accuracy rates above 90% when reviewing contracts.

Risks

• Benchmark tests reveal hallucination rates as high as 58% for leading large language models when asked about case law.
• Courts have already sanctioned attorneys for submitting filings with fabricated citations.

Efficiency is attractive—but without human judgment, errors can cost far more than the time saved.

Perspectives from the Legal Community

Legal leaders increasingly see AI as a supplement, not a substitute.

• Eleanor Lightbody, CEO of Luminance, recently noted that AI may shrink certain junior tasks but can also serve as a “teacher,” accelerating training for younger lawyers.
• Goldman Sachs estimates that roughly 17% of legal work could be automated—serious, but far from a wholesale replacement of the profession.
• Judges, bar associations, and state regulators emphasize a lawyer’s duty to supervise AI outputs, reinforcing that final accountability always rests with humans.

The consensus is clear: AI is a powerful tool, but it cannot replace the ethical judgment, strategic thinking, and accountability of licensed attorneys.

The Regulatory Lens

AI in legal review is also drawing scrutiny from regulators:

• State attorneys general have warned major AI vendors about risks to consumers and professional misuse, signaling tighter oversight to come.
• In Iowa, disciplinary authorities struck filings that included fake AI-generated citations, underscoring that even candidates for admission to the bar are not immune from accountability.

This growing scrutiny means firms cannot afford to experiment recklessly. They need safe, lawyer-centered tools that keep efficiency while protecting against risk.

NexLaw: AI That Supports, Not Replaces

Artificial intelligence should never substitute legal judgment. Instead, it should elevate the capabilities of attorneys and legal teams while embedding critical safeguards into everyday workflows. That is exactly what NEXLAW was built for—helping U.S. lawyers leverage AI responsibly, without sacrificing accuracy or compliance.

NEXA: Smarter Legal Research With Built-In Control

• Searches across trusted legal databases to minimize hallucination risks
• Highlights questionable citations so attorneys can manually review before including them in filings
• Reduces time spent on repetitive research while keeping human oversight front and center

TRIALPREP: Speed Without Sacrificing Oversight

• Streamlines motion drafting, discovery review, and trial strategy building
• Includes validation checkpoints requiring attorney review and sign-off
• Helps teams work faster while meeting ethical and procedural obligations

CHRONOVAULT 2.0: Full Transparency From Start to Finish

• Tracks each AI-generated suggestion, revision, and decision point
• Creates an audit-ready trail that supports internal quality reviews and external regulatory inquiries
• Allows firms to demonstrate diligence, professionalism, and compliance at every stage

Example in Practice

A paralegal working on a motion uses NEXA to locate supporting case law. One citation is flagged as potentially outdated. The team verifies it using TRIALPREP and records the entire process in CHRONOVAULT 2.0. This workflow combines speed with clarity and protects the firm from reputational or disciplinary risk.

Key Lessons for U.S. Legal Teams

• AI is now integral to modern legal work. Avoiding it is no longer practical.
• Human judgment is non-negotiable. Legal accountability stays with the attorney.
• Choosing AI built specifically for law, like NEXLAW, provides essential guardrails.
• Documenting every decision, change, and output is no longer optional—it is the new industry standard.

Modern AI Should Protect, Not Replace, Lawyers

The real shift in the legal industry is not about replacement. It is about transformation. Firms that pair AI efficiency with human validation will strengthen their output, reduce costly errors, and retain client trust.

NEXLAW provides the structure, oversight, and transparency needed to achieve that balance.

• Start with a 3-day free trial—no credit card required
• Prefer full access to every feature? Choose the 7-day free trial with advanced capabilities
• Need guidance on how to implement NexLaw at your firm? Book a demo call with our legal solutions team